Watson Vs. House M.D.

Could Watson may be more than just a game show contestant? IBM thinks so.

“Watson, within seconds, will be able to search all recent medical research information and help the doctor make that [diagnosis] and perhaps most importantly, recommend the best practice in the world for that patient at that second.”

This got me thinking—what would the ramifications of this be for our beloved Dr. Gregory House?

Think of all misdiagnoses and wrong treatments that nearly kill every single one of House’s patients. This could all potentially be avoided.

Imagine House sitting at a table humiliating his staff and ordering them to break into someone’s house and treat their dying patient for cancer, then lupus, then sarcoidosis, then some vague desease simply referred to as “autoimmune,” before realizing it’s almost never any of those things even though they always guess them first, and finally having the correct diagnosis revealed to him, unwittingly, by Wilson.

Now imagine instead of underlings and Wilson down the hall, he has a terminal in his office linked to Watson. He punches in the symptoms and history of his patient and in seconds Watson speaks the correct diagnosis: “What is AIDS?”

So maybe there are a few kinks to work out, but you can see my point—poor Dr. House suddenly finds himself with a boring job, a seven minute television program, and way fewer epiphanic moments.

Watson for President

Last night aired the first of three Jeopardy! episodes featuring Watson, IBM‘s latest in their quest to make computers smarter than humans.

I was impressed. Without giving too much away to those who have yet to see Watson compete against Jeopardy! giants Ken Jennings and Brad Rutter, let me just say that watching a computer break down, analyze, and interpret the metaphor and pun filled nuances of human language in Jeopardy! questions was nothing short of awe-inspiring.

This goes far beyond the accomplishment of Deep Blue, IBM’s computer chess champion of the late 90s. While chess can be boiled down to following the straight-forward (though complex) logic of mathematics, something that computers have always excelled at, Jeopardy! requires an understanding of language, something that computers have been notoriously bad at. Computation vs comprehension.

Perhaps the most impressive part is that Watson does it all with the knowledge stored in his “brain” just like his human competitors—no internet access. He also must physically press the buzzer just like everyone else.

Although Watson is a large set of bundled IBM servers represented by a non-humanoid avatar on a screen, you’ll notice I keep using the pronoun “he” when referring to—him. That’s because his ability to compete at something so exclusively human personifies him. I feel like Alex, Ken, and Brad must have fought the urge to include Watson in their after-show conversation. Imagine if Watson looked like a person and was able to see and hear! (At one point Jennings incorrectly answered a question after which Watson buzzed in giving the same wrong answer.)

It lets one’s mind open up to the possibility of ideas once relegated to the imagination. Could a more sophisticated version in the future contain enough information and learn well enough to simulate human emotion? How would we handle such a development—give robots rights? Sounds crazy, but let’s be honest, we all grew pretty attached to Data, did we not?

So maybe I get a little carried away. We are, of course, still in the very early stages of artificial intelligence and Watson is designed very specifically for analytics, but it makes you think.

Watson continues his battle tonight. I suggest you all tune in.

In case you missed day 1, click here to watch.

How Watson works (they reveal the results of the practice round with Ken and Brad in this video):

Happy Darwin Day!

Today we celebrate the birth of Charles Darwin. Maybe you’ve heard of him. I’m going to the Cleveland Museum of Natural History with the Cleveland Freethinkers to see the Extreme Mammals exhibit!

What are you doing?


Eye for an Eye?

In a recent episode of Dogma Free America, they discuss a story about Britain’s Orthodox Jews being instructed by their Chief Rabbi not to be organ donors. (Side note: If you haven’t tried the Dogma Free America podcast, I highly recommend checking it out here.) In the episode, they consider the prospect of only allowing organ donors to receive organ transplants. This is an interesting idea—the waiting list in the US alone is more than 100,000 and this would surely help to balance the supply and demand, but is it ethical? I thought this would make a good poll.

 

Now that you’ve put in your two cents, have fun playing Organ Trail, the zombie version of Oregon Trail.

PODCAST: Dr. Darrel Ray

 


Download this episode (right click and save)

 

 

Guy welcomes the autor of The God Virus and founder of Recovering from Religion, Dr. Darrel Ray.

Stuff we talk about in this episode:

New theme music, “Lazy White Atheist Blues,” by T. Randolph Scott

More Potential Faith-Eaters

I caught this article through PZ about the Christian faith-healers killers of Followers of Christ Church. It seems this particular religion is hell-bent on killing their kids. I should get these people to join my faith-eating cause.

The Wylands’ 7-month-old daughter, Alayna, was placed in state custody earlier this month after child-welfare workers received a tip about the untreated and ballooning growth. Doctors said that the condition could cause permanent damage or loss of vision.

This is what happens when people reject science and indulge in superstition. This is why it’s important to be vocal about our skepticism—silly beliefs aren’t always harmless.

Like This!

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine

PODCAST: Michael Largo




Download this episode (right click and save)

Michael Largo comes on the show to discuss his new book, God’s Lunatics, available June 22.

Links:

Stuff we talk about in this episode:

Like This!

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine

PODCAST: theGuy


 

or Download this episode (right click and save)


more about “Inside the Atheists Studio“, posted with vodpod

Guy becomes a guest on his own show while Johnny fills in as host.
Links:

Stuff we talk about in this episode:

Music by Steadman

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine

PODCAST: lukeprog

Listen here
or
Download (right click and save)

Luke Muehlhauser, author of the blog Common Sense Atheism as well as the Conversations from the Pale Blue Dot podcast.

More Luke links:

Stuff we talk about in this episode:

Please comment or email by using the Contact page.

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine

Open Letter to Facebook Friends

Dear Facebook friends,

I’d like to inform you about a brand spanking new feature called the hide button. It magically appears when you roll your mouse cursor over the top right portion of any post. See below.

This button allows you to prevent any individual’s posts from appearing on your news feed. This comes in handy when when your feed is inundated with posts about atheism, science, religion, philosophy, politics—you know, trivial stuff that doesn’t interest you.

Feel free to use this magic button on me—I probably already hid you after that post about that celebrity or trend. Or you can remove me from your friends altogether. Anything to help make your Facebook experience more enjoyable.

Evanescently your friend,

Guy

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 451 other followers